Skip to main content

10 Facts about the Mafia Cops



Louis Eppolito and Stephen Caracappa spent most of their adult lives working as decorated detectives from the New York Police Department.  Deep down inside the boys in blue traded their badge of honor, for the fast cash of being mafia hitmen.  They went on to retire and move from New York City to Las Vegas.  The only issue with both detectives was that they were on the payroll of the Lucchese Crime family, and mafia associates would soon rate them out.  They were added to the payroll by the Underboss at the time Anthony “Gaspipe” Casso then Underboss of the family.  They were arrested, convicted, and sentenced to life in prison and fined a large amount of money.


  Eppolito’s father, Gambino Crime Family soldier

Lou Eppolito’s grandfather, father and uncle were all members of the Gambino Crime family.  They were all involved in common mafia rackets, loan sharking, numbers running, extortion and money laundering.   His father’s name was Ralph Eppolito.  Ralph was an old-time member of the Gambino Crime family, he had been inducted into the family by Carlo Gambino.  As a young teenager Eppolito’s dad would bring him to his social club and teach Lou about the mafia ways.  Lou’s grandfather came to the United States around the turn of the 20th century.  Later, he ran rackets with Lucky Luciano, and Carlo Gambino.  Lou Eppolito was born into a family of mobsters. At 12 years-old, Lou started to work in his father’s bar, and he soon started to give envelopes of money to police sitting in their squad cars nearby.

  Lou Eppolito gets Involved with the NYPD

At his father’s funeral, mobsters were giving Lou Eppolito envelopes of and cards. The envelopes and the cards contained information to get jobs at various sectors in New York City controlled by the mafia.   Lou and his wife had just had a baby and he was working a dead-end job.  He called a mobster and was soon set up with a job at the Manhattan Central Post office.  The job did not last long so Lou Eppolito decided to help a friend get ready for the physical portion of the NYPD Police exam.   Lou decided to take the exam and he passed.  He was filling out a pre-employment questionnaire when it asked “if you or anyone in your family has been arrested or convicted of a felony please outline here” Lou Filled out the sheet honestly.  The recruiting officer asked about Lou’s family and since he was honest, he was given the green light.  In the 1960s crime in New York City was increasing and a lot of young men were fighting in Vietnam.  In, 1969 he was hired and 6 months later assigned to Brooklyn’s 63rd street precinct.  His beat took him to the streets where his family ran rackets for over 60 years. 

3   Stephen Caracappa dies in Prison

Stephen Caracappa was serving his time in a medical detention facility in North Carolina.  Caracappa was 75 years old at the time of his death.  He passed away on April 8, 2017.  By 2016 Caracappa had exhausted all his appeals, and would spend the rest of his life in prison, he attempted to petition a federal judge for early release because he had been suffering from cancer.  The federal judge declined to do anything stating that it was out of his hands.   Carracappa hand wrote his letter.

4   Mafia Cops Arrested and Convicted

On March 9, 2005, they were arrested in Las Vegas.  On March 13, 2006, the trial began.  They faced charges for 10 murders, obstruction of justice, drug distribution, and money laundering.  The indictments against Caracappa and Eppolito state that they were involved with the mafia from May 16, 1979-March 9, 2005.  Burton Kaplan testified against both mafia cops.  Kaplan stated that the partnership between the mafia cops and the Lucchese family was from 1986-1993.  Kaplan testified that he delivered information between the mafia cops and Anthony Casso for much of those years.  On April 6, 2006 both Eppolito and Caracappa were convicted by a Jury.  The judge was not convinced and threw out the conviction.  The court of appeals reversed the decision.  They were both sentenced to life in prison.  Eppolito was sentenced to life plus 100 years, and Caracappa was given life plus 80 years.  They were each fined 4 million dollars.  Both cops denied the charges, and conviction, Eppolito apologized to the families of the victims.  Both mafia cops at the time of writing this article had exhausted their appeals. 

5   Eppolito writes a book

Eppolito wrote a book about his life in the mafia while he was a kid, and being an NYPD cop.  The book was published in 1992.  The book had pictures, and in one of them there was Eppolito and Caracappa with a caption that read “The Two godfathers of the NYPD”.  Eppolito went on a book tour and appeared on Sally Jesse Raphael’s TV show.  Jimmy Hydell’s mother was watching the show, she bought the book, and she could ID the two cops that interviewed her son, on the day that Jimmy Hydell went missing.  Hydell’s mother informed the NYPD what she saw that day.  For the first-time NYPD detectives, could place a connection between Eppolito, Caracappa and Jimmy Hydell.  Had Eppolito not written the book it is possible that they would have gotten away with their crimes.

6   Robbery Division

Caracappa was the good cop, and Eppolito was the bad cop so to speak.  They both had access to sensitive information, the kind of information that mobsters would pay a lot of money for.  The NYPD job provided a lot of cover, they eventually launched a criminal enterprise.  In the early 80s they were split up, by the mid-80s Caracappa was in an organized squad of the NYPD. Lou Eppolito’s fingerprints were found on Police reports found hidden in the home of a heroin dealer Rosario Gambino.  Eppolito decided to fight for his job, he stood trial in an NYPD internal investigation.  The judge determined that there was not enough evidence to convict, Eppolito returned to the job.  In the mid-80s Caracappa’s position allowed him to look at information that the FBI and NYPD family had on the Lucchese and Genovese family.  For three years, these two families knew about every bug and every informant that was cooperating against the families.  

   Anthony Casso is Arrested.

In Early May of 1990 Lou Eppolito informed Casso through Burton Kaplan that he was going to be arrested.  Eppolito now retired, called Kaplan from Las Vegas, he said that he received the information from Caracappa who was still an NYPD detective.  On May 7, 1990 Anthony Casso became a fugitive.  The government had wiretapped Casso’s associates.  Casso would call from cell phones and with this information the government tracked him down. Casso was arrested in New Jersey while he was hiding out.
To save his life he flipped on Kaplan, Eppolito, and Caracappa.  Casso became an unreliable witness because his story kept changing, but the information was useful.  Casso revealed that throughout the years that the mafia cops worked for him, he paid them over $350,000. 

Burton Kaplan and Eppolito’s cousin

Eppolito’s cousin Frank Santoro met a Jewish Mobster, Bert Kaplan while doing a stint in prison.  Santoro told Kaplan that he had a cousin on the NYPD and if he ever needed any favors to let him know.  At the time, Frank Santoro was associated with the Gambino family.  Santoro even offered to do murders for Kaplan.  Initially Kaplan had concerns about working with cops, but Santoro reassured him that he worked with the cops before and they could be trusted.  Kaplan had a racket selling stolen treasury bonds, and he suspected that he was being ripped off by a jeweler named Israel Greenwald, Kaplan found out that he was about to be ratted out to the feds.  Kaplan offered 30000 dollars for the hit. On February 10, 1986, the detectives staked out Greenwald’s home.  Greenwald left and he was subsequently pulled over by them.  They asked the jeweler to come to the police station to participate in a lineup because he was a suspect in a hit and run, and he agreed.  Instead of going to the station, they drove him to an auto repair shop in Brooklyn where Santoro was waiting.  Santoro shot Greenwald dead.  Santoro forced the garage owner to bury the body inside the warehouse.  Santoro made $5,000, Eppolito and Caracappa split up $25,000.  Santoro was killed in 1987 thereafter Kaplan met with Eppolito and or Caracappa late at night in a private place, busy highway, and cemeteries near Staten Island. 

     Mafia Cops, Lucchese Family and Jimmy Hydell

Casso was shot and wanted revenge.  Kaplan informed Casso that he had a friend whose cousin works in the 63rd Precinct and that he could probably help with identifying the attackers.  Kaplan informed Casso of the help he received from them regarding the Greenwald assassination.  The attempted hit on Casso occurred in Brooklyn 63rd precinct where Eppolito worked at the time.   Casso sent word through Kaplan who acted as the middleman to get information from the cops.  A few days later Kaplan gave Casso information about suspects, the first one was Jimmy Hydell, a Gambino Crime Family associate.   The mafia cops gave the information to Santoro who gave it to Kaplan, Santoro told him it was a gift from the mafia cops, and these are some of the things they would do.  Kaplan proposed that the cops could deliver Hydell to Casso.  On October 18, 1986 Eppolito and Caracappa staked out Hydell’s house.  The cops interviewed Jimmy’s brother, Frank Hydell and they found out where Jimmy was.  During the interview the mom got a good look of the two cops.  They met up with Jimmy later, who assumed he was being arrested.  They hog tied jimmy and threw him in the truck, the keys were given to Frank Santoro.  Eppolito followed Santoro where they observed Santoro give the keys to Casso and Kaplan.  At the bodyshop it was the first time that all 5 men had seen each other.  Casso took the keys from Kaplan and told everyone else to leave.  Jimmy Hydell was tortured in a Brooklyn basement, his body was never found.  Eppolito and Caracappa each received $30,000, Santoro received $5,000.

Nicky Guido

Jimmy Hydell revealed that Nicky Guido, and Eddie Lino where the others that tried to kill Casso.  Casso asked the detectives for information but they only had a name.  They came up with a name and address but wanted more money from Casso to investigate further, he refused because he had given a $5,000 bonus for Delivering Hydell, Santoro kept this money and never told Eppolito or Caracappa. All this information was being funneled through Kaplan.  December 25, 1986 Nicky Guido is killed in front of his home in Brooklyn, but it was the wrong Nicky Guido.  The Guido that they were looking for lived in upstate New York.  Casso wanted to make sure that this never happens again and put the mafia cops on the payroll at 4000 dollars a month.   Burt Kaplan was very upset about the wrong Nicky Guido’s murder.  Kaplan flipped and over the course of the next few months he linked Eppolito, and Caracappa to numerous murders.  Nicky Guido’s mother would go on to receive a settlement from the City of New York for 5 million dollars.





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Life and Times of Lucchese Underboss Anthony Casso

Anthony Salvatore Casso was born on May 21, 1940, in Brooklyn, New York.  Casso was raised in the Park Slope neighborhood of Brooklyn, and it was a haven for La Cosa Nostra.  It is here where Casso fell in love with the mobster life.  Casso’s father was not in the mafia, but he knew connected guys.  Casso’s dad was so close to the mafia that he had a mobster Sally Callinbrano Baptize "little baby" Casso.  Casso’s father Michael carried a lead gas pipe, he was not a mobster, but it is this reason that Casso was given the nickname of Gaspipe. As a teenager, Casso started hanging out with a local gang; he was a lousy student and preferred street life.  Casso’s godfather Sonny gave him his first job at the docks.  The job did not require Casso to show up for work, and he would receive a paycheck regardless.  In the evenings, Casso started high jacking trucks, and he became a partner in a local bar.  Casso Becomes Underboss In the mid-80s, many mob bosses were faci

The Grim Reaper: Gregory Scarpa a Colombo Family Hitman

In the late 1960s the FBI faces heavy criticism in its handling of the safety of African Americans in the south.   In the south the FBI is facing a tough enemy, the local citizens, cops, local government, and member of the Ku Klux Klan. January 10, 1966 the home of Vernon Dahmer, President of a local NAACP chapter is attacked by members of the White Nights of the Ku Klux Klan.   The KKK started shooting at the Dahmer house with shotguns, then they started throwing gas jugs at the home.   Dahmer’s home, car, and grocery store were destroyed in the fire.   Vernon Dahmer suffered massive burns to his upper body.   Dahmer later died at the hospital.   The F.B.I. calls the New York office and requested the use of informant NY-3461 for a special assignment.   The informant is later identified as a member of the Colombo Family Gregory Scarpa.   Scarpa would go on to lead a very unique life, a hitman, and informant, and a family man.   How was a Profaci/Colombo family hitman recruited

The Death of Salvatore Maranzano

Savatore Maranzano September 10, 1931, Helmsley Building, New York City.   A team of hitmen enter the building and head to the 9 th floor, where Maranzano’s office is located.   The hit team posed as cops and federal lawmen so as not to alarm the guards that Maranzano had in place.   The hit team disarmed the guards as they made their way up to Maranzano’s office.   The hit team consisted of four members, Vito Genovese, Albert Anastasia, JoeAdonis , and Samuel Levine . Maranzano is grabbed and pinned up against the wall, he is repeatedly stabbed.   Knife wounds to the chest, stomach, face, Maranzano is strangled, and finally the hit team pumps six rounds into his lifeless body.   Why did Maranzano suffer the same fate as his former nemesis Joe Masseria, six months after killing him?   Who ordered Maranzano’s death? Early Years Salvatore Maranzano was born on July 31, 1886 in Castellammare del Golfo, Sicily, Italy.   As a young Sicilian boy Maranzano had inter